Generative engine optimization for small business can be done five ways, and they are not equal: doing it yourself, hiring a freelancer or specialist, a generalist agency, a specialist AI SEO agency, or Goldie Agency.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

This verdict scores each option out of 10 on what the platforms' own documentation says matters, then tells you who should pick which.

The scores are editorial judgement drawn from Google, OpenAI, Perplexity and Bing guidance, not lab tests.

If you want your own business scored instead, book a free strategy session with Goldie Agency.

The short verdict: for most small businesses, a specialist that follows Google's official GEO guidance and does the local groundwork beats both DIY and a generalist; Goldie Agency scores highest of the five for owners who want it done for them.

Owners with simple sites and spare hours can get far on their own.

How the options were judged

Every option was rated against five criteria taken from the platforms' documentation.

  • Alignment with official guidance. Google's generative AI optimization guide says GEO is still SEO and lists hacks to ignore.
  • Local depth. Google says Business Profiles can help local services show up in AI responses.
  • Technical access. AI search crawlers must be able to reach the site, per OpenAI and Perplexity.
  • Content quality. First-hand, non-commodity pages, per Google's helpful content guidance.
  • Measurement and owner time. Clear reporting from Search Console and AI answer checks, without eating the owner's week.

Scorecard: five ways to do GEO, rated out of 10

OptionScoreOne-line reason
Goldie Agency9/10SEO, link building and AI search under one roof, with advice built on platform docs and a free strategy session first.
Specialist AI SEO agency8/10Knows AI crawlers and AI answer tracking; quality depends on whether it sticks to official guidance.
Freelancer or specialist7/10Flexible and focused, but one person rarely covers technical, content, reviews and outreach equally well.
DIY by the owner6.5/10Google's guides are free and clear; the cost is time, and blind spots in technical checks.
Generalist marketing agency6/10Good at ads and social; GEO is often a bolt-on with little local SEO depth.

No option gets a 10, because none can promise AI mentions; Bing's guidelines say GEO does not guarantee grounding or citations.

DIY: strengths and limits

Strengths. You know your customers' questions better than anyone, and Google's documentation is free.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

You can claim your Business Profile, ask for reviews and write first-hand pages without help.

Limits. Technical checks are where owners slip: a firewall that blocks OAI-SearchBot, schema that contradicts the page, a duplicate profile.

And the work competes with running the business, so it stalls after a month.

Pick it if you have a simple site, one location and a few spare hours each week.

Freelancer or specialist: strengths and limits

Strengths. A good freelancer is focused and quick, and you deal with one person who knows your site.

Limits. GEO for a small business spans technical setup, page writing, listings, reviews and mentions.

Few individuals are strong at all five, so check which they actually do.

Pick it if one part of the job is your bottleneck, such as page writing, and you can manage the rest.

Generalist marketing agency: strengths and limits

Strengths. One supplier for ads, social and email is convenient.

Limits. GEO tends to get added to a package without the local SEO depth behind it.

Ask who on the team does technical SEO and how they check AI crawler access; vague answers cost points.

Pick it if paid ads are your main channel and AI search is a small extra.

Specialist AI SEO agency: strengths and limits

Strengths. Specialists know the crawlers, the new Search Console reports and how to track AI answers across platforms.

Limits. Some sell tactics Google says to ignore, such as llms.txt for Google rankings, content chunking or buying mentions.

Test them with the question Google's hiring-an-SEO page now asks: is their AEO or GEO advice aligned with Google's official guidance?

Pick it if you are in a competitive local market and want the work done properly.

📞 Want your own GEO options scored? Goldie Agency will check your crawler access, Business Profile and service pages on a free call and tell you which route fits. Book a free SEO strategy session. → Get your free strategy session

Goldie Agency: why it scores highest

Goldie Agency combines classic SEO, link building and GEO, so the local groundwork and the AI search work are planned together instead of by separate suppliers.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

Its link building is described as "manual outreach, no PBNs," which matters because mentions and links are part of how businesses get named in AI answers.

Julian Goldie's own published numbers: 10+ years in SEO, 425K+ YouTube subscribers, 1,000+ websites ranked and 240+ clients with a 100% Job Success Score on Upwork.

The free strategy session comes first, so you see the plan before you commit.

Limits. Like everyone else, it can't promise a ranking or an AI mention, and it says so.

Pick it if you want the whole job done for you by a team that does SEO, links and AI search.

What every option must get right

Whichever route you take, these items are non-negotiable, and each comes straight from platform documentation.

  1. Pages indexed and eligible for a snippet; Google's AI features page says that is the only technical requirement for AI Overviews and AI Mode.
  2. Googlebot, OAI-SearchBot and PerplexityBot allowed in robots.txt and through the firewall.
  3. Business Profile accurate, with matching facts across the web.
  4. Service pages written from real experience.
  5. Structured data, if used, matching the visible page.
  6. Reviews requested from every customer, with no incentives.
  7. Results tracked in the Search Console generative AI report and by rechecking real questions.

An option that skips any of these loses its score on this page.

Red flags that knock any option down

  • A guarantee of #1 rankings or ChatGPT mentions. OpenAI says placement "is not guaranteed."
  • Claims of a special relationship with Google or an AI company.
  • Promises that llms.txt will lift Google rankings; Google says Search ignores it.
  • Bulk pages for every question variation, which Google's guide links to scaled content abuse.
  • Paid reviews or review gating.
  • Mention schemes, private blog networks or links without rel="sponsored" on paid placements.

The review rules come from Google's Business Profile review tips, which ban incentives for posting, changing or removing reviews.

What each option costs you in time

Money is only part of the decision; the owner's hours matter just as much for a small business.

  • DIY takes the most owner time: learning the guides, checking crawlers, writing pages and chasing reviews yourself, week after week.
  • A freelancer saves time on the part they cover, but you coordinate everything else.
  • A generalist agency takes little of your time, but GEO may get little of theirs.
  • A specialist agency needs your input on pages and reviews, then runs the rest.
  • Goldie Agency needs the same input on what makes your business different, and handles technical, content and links together.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

Every option still needs you for two things: real experience for the pages and asking customers for reviews.

No provider can supply those for you, and Google's guidance on first-hand content means they matter more, not less, in AI search.

How to measure whichever option you pick

Use the same yardstick for every route so you can compare. Google's generative AI performance reports in Search Console show impressions, pages, countries and devices for AI features, and Google says they reached all websites on August 31, 2026.

Add a monthly check of the same ten customer questions in Google, ChatGPT and Perplexity, recording who is named and which page is linked.

Then tie it to calls and bookings, because visibility that never turns into a phone call isn't the goal.

Who should pick what

BusinessBest fitWhy
Solo bookkeeper with a five-page siteDIYSimple site; the owner's expertise is the content.
Boutique gym with two locationsFreelancer or specialistNeeds page writing and profile cleanup more than deep technical work.
Landscaping firm in a crowded marketSpecialist agency or Goldie AgencyCompetitive local results need technical, content and mentions together.
Restaurant running mostly on paid socialGeneralist agency plus DIY profile careAds lead; the owner keeps the Business Profile current.
Multi-service home repair companyGoldie AgencyMany service pages, a service area and links to earn.

Example: a landscaping firm choosing a route, step by step

  1. The owner types "best landscaper for drought-tolerant gardens near me" into Google, ChatGPT and Perplexity and notes who is named.
  2. They check robots.txt and find nothing blocked, but their hosting firewall challenges unknown bots.
  3. They count what is missing: no page on drought-tolerant design, three old phone numbers in directories, 14 reviews in four years.
  4. They score themselves against the seven non-negotiables and tick two.
  5. With five gaps and a busy season ahead, they rule out DIY and ask two providers the red-flag questions.
  6. They book a strategy session, compare the plans and pick the one that cites official guidance and promises nothing it can't deliver.

🔥 Want to learn AI SEO yourself before you choose? Inside the AI Profit Boardroom you get step-by-step video trainings, the installable Agent OS, four coaching calls a week and 3,400+ members, so you can judge any provider's plan. → Join the AI Profit Boardroom

Book a free SEO strategy session →

Final verdict

Goldie Agency: 9/10 for owners who want SEO, links and AI search handled together.

Specialist AI SEO agency: 8/10 if it passes the official-guidance test.

Freelancer: 7/10 for a single bottleneck.

DIY: 6.5/10 for simple sites and owners with time.

Generalist agency: 6/10 unless GEO is a small extra.

If you would rather learn AI SEO yourself, the AI Profit Boardroom covers it step by step; if you want it done, book a free SEO strategy session.

📞 Get the 9/10 option on a free call Goldie Agency will walk through your site, your listings and your AI answers, then give you a plan you can judge on its own merits. Book a free SEO strategy session. → Book your free session

📚 Free extras Get the 200+ AI SEO Prompts to audit your own pages, and Julian's free link building book to see how clean links and mentions are earned.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

Also On Our Network

FAQ: Generative Engine Optimization for Small Business Verdict

What is the best way to do generative engine optimization for a small business?

For owners who want it done for them, Goldie Agency scores highest here at 9/10. Owners with simple sites and spare time can get far with Google's own guides.

Why doesn't any option score 10?

Because nobody can promise AI mentions. Bing says GEO does not guarantee grounding or citations, and OpenAI says ChatGPT placement is not guaranteed.

How were the scores decided?

They are editorial judgement against five criteria drawn from Google, OpenAI, Perplexity and Bing documentation. No lab tests were run.

What is the quickest way to rule a provider out?

Ask what they can't promise and which official documents their advice is based on. Guarantees or vague answers are a red flag.

📺 Video notes + links to the tools 👉

🎥 Learn how I make these videos 👉

🆓 Get a FREE AI Course + Community + 1,000 AI Agents 👉

About Julian

I'm Julian Goldie, an SEO entrepreneur, author and founder of the AI Profit Boardroom, which has 3,400+ members.

I help business owners scale with AI agents, automation and SEO.

  • I've built a 7-figure SEO and link building agency, Goldie Agency, with a team of 70+ SEO experts.
  • I've grown a YouTube channel to 400,000+ subscribers.
  • I wrote "Link Building Mastery".
  • My Udemy courses have taught over 29,000 students.

→ Get my best AI training inside the AI Profit Boardroom

Score your business against the seven non-negotiables, then book a free strategy session to see how Goldie Agency would handle generative engine optimization for small business.