AEO for ecommerce can be done by the store owner, a freelancer, a generalist agency or a specialist team, and the right pick depends on catalogue size more than anything else.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
This verdict rates those options out of 10 against what Google, OpenAI, Perplexity and Bing actually document for online stores.
The ratings are editorial judgement based on those docs, not test results.
To see where your own store lands, book a free SEO strategy session and we'll score it with you.
The short verdict
For a small catalogue with a hands-on owner, DIY with good training is enough.
For a catalogue in the hundreds, with feeds, variants and templates to manage, a specialist team wins on depth and on speed.
Goldie Agency rates highest here for stores that want SEO, AEO and link building handled together, with the free strategy session as the first step.
Whoever does it, the work is the same set of jobs, and no option can guarantee an AI mention.
How the options were judged
Each option was scored on five things a store needs, all taken from platform documentation.
- Technical depth: product markup, feeds, crawler rules and preview controls.
- Content capacity: turning buyer questions into useful product page copy at catalogue scale.
- Policy safety: staying inside Google's review, spam and structured data rules.
- Measurement: reporting from Search Console, Bing and ChatGPT Business Hub.
- Owner time: how much of your own week the option demands.
Scorecard: who should run AEO for an online store
| Option | Rating | One-line reason |
|---|---|---|
| DIY (owner-run) | 6/10 | Cheapest in cash and you know the products best, but markup, feeds and reporting eat your week. |
| Freelancer or specialist | 7/10 | Strong on one skill such as schema or copy, but one person rarely covers feeds, content and reporting together. |
| Generalist agency | 6/10 | Plenty of hands, but ecommerce markup and AI crawler rules are often treated as an afterthought. |
| Specialist AEO or ecommerce SEO agency | 8/10 | Covers the whole stack with process, though fit depends on how well they know your platform. |
| Goldie Agency (Julian's team) | 9/10 | SEO, GEO, AEO and link building under one roof, with manual outreach, no PBNs, and a free strategy session first. |
A 10 isn't on the table for anyone, because no provider controls whether an engine picks your product.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
๐ Want your store scored against this table? Book a free SEO strategy session and we'll check your product markup, crawler rules and feeds, then tell you which option fits. โ Get your store's verdict
The baseline every option must deliver
Whoever you pick, these five jobs are non-negotiable, and each comes straight from the docs.
- Allow Googlebot, OAI-SearchBot and PerplexityBot, as the OpenAI and Perplexity crawler pages recommend for search visibility.
- Add Product markup with a nested Offer to every buyable product page, per Google's merchant listing guide.
- Send a Merchant Center feed as well: Google's product intro says "Providing both structured data on web pages and a Merchant Center feed maximizes your eligibility to experiences."
- Write product pages that answer buyer questions with first-hand detail.
- Collect real reviews within the review snippet guidelines.
If a proposal doesn't mention all five, it isn't a full AEO plan for a store.
DIY: strengths and limits
Strengths: you know the products, the customers and the questions better than anyone you could hire.
Google's merchant listing guide notes that a plugin built into your store platform can make markup easier, and its product data page says smaller sites can start with an automated feed built from crawled pages.
Limits: markup errors, price mismatches between page and feed, and blocked crawlers are easy to miss without a checklist.
Best for: a catalogue small enough to review page by page, and an owner willing to learn the work step by step.
Freelancer or specialist: strengths and limits
Strengths: a good schema or technical freelancer can fix a product template in a short engagement and leave clear notes.
Limits: AEO for a store crosses markup, feeds, copy, reviews and reporting, and one person usually owns one or two of those.
Best for: a store with a single clear problem, such as broken markup after a theme change.
Ask a freelancer for a sample of product markup they have shipped and run it through the Rich Results Test yourself before hiring.
If their work passes and they explain each field, you have found someone worth keeping for future fixes.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Generalist agency: strengths and limits
Strengths: capacity for content and campaigns, and often paid ads under the same roof.
Limits: AI crawler rules, preview controls and merchant listing requirements are niche, and a generalist team may not check them.
Best for: stores that mainly need more product content and already have clean technical foundations.
Ask a generalist agency how they would treat OAI-SearchBot versus GPTBot, because the answer shows quickly whether AI search is part of their process.
OpenAI documents the two as independent settings, so a confident, correct answer is a good sign.
Specialist AEO or ecommerce SEO agency: strengths and limits
Strengths: a repeatable process across crawlers, markup, feeds and AI reporting.
Limits: a specialist still needs your product knowledge, and platform fit matters, so ask which store systems they've worked on.
Best for: catalogues in the hundreds or more, frequent stock changes and several product variants.
Ask how they keep markup, feed and page in sync when prices change, since Google's merchant listing guide says it may verify product data before showing it.
Goldie Agency: strengths and limits
Strengths: the Goldie Agency strategy session is free, and the agency lists SEO, GEO, AEO and link building as core services.
Julian's own published numbers cite 1,000+ SEO and link building campaigns, 240+ clients and a 100% Job Success Score on Upwork.
Link building is done with manual outreach, no PBNs, which matters for stores that need links into product guides and category pages.
Limits: like everyone else, the team can't promise placement, and the work still needs product facts and approvals from you.
Best for: stores that want ranking, AI visibility and links handled by one team instead of three suppliers.
How the options compare on each criterion
The overall ratings hide some useful detail, so here is the spread by criterion.
| Criterion | Strongest option | Weakest option | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Technical depth | Specialist agency, Goldie Agency | DIY | Markup, feeds and crawler rules reward a repeatable checklist. |
| Content capacity | Generalist agency, Goldie Agency | Freelancer | Rewriting hundreds of product pages needs several writers. |
| Policy safety | Specialist agency | Any option that cuts corners | Review and spam rules punish shortcuts, whoever takes them. |
| Measurement | Specialist agency, Goldie Agency | DIY | Three reporting tools across Google, Bing and ChatGPT take discipline to track. |
| Owner time | Goldie Agency, specialist agency | DIY | Done-for-you options leave you with approvals and product facts only. |
Book a free SEO strategy session →
DIY loses on four of five criteria but wins on product knowledge, which is why it still earns a 6.
That knowledge is the raw material for every answer an engine might quote, so no outside option can replace it.
The best outside teams are the ones that pull it out of you quickly, with a short interview per product line rather than a long questionnaire.
Red flags that sink any option
Drop any provider to zero if you hear one of these.
- Guaranteed placement: Google's hiring page says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, and Bing says GEO doesn't guarantee citations.
- llms.txt as the Google fix: Google's generative AI guide says Search ignores those files, so it doesn't help or hurt Google visibility.
- Review schemes: buying reviews, or giving free products for reviews without making that clear, breaks Google's rules.
- Page farms: hundreds of near-identical pages for every question variant, which Google ties to its scaled content abuse policy.
- Secret methods: Google's hiring page warns against companies that won't explain what they plan to do.
Who should pick what
Use the size of your catalogue as the first filter, then your time.
- Under about 50 products, owner has time: DIY, with training and a monthly checklist.
- Under about 50 products, owner has no time: a freelancer for the setup, then DIY upkeep.
- Hundreds of products, one platform: a specialist agency or Goldie Agency.
- Hundreds of products plus link building needs: Goldie Agency, so content, AEO and links share one plan.
A garden supplies store with 40 products and a keen owner is case one.
A homeware brand with 900 variants across three currencies is case three or four.
That brand also needs a separate URL per currency, which Google's merchant listing guide asks for, so the technical load alone points away from DIY.
A 20-minute test before you choose
Run this on your own store before any sales call.
- Paste three product URLs into Google's Rich Results Test and note any missing required fields.
- Open yoursite.com/robots.txt and check that OAI-SearchBot and PerplexityBot aren't disallowed.
- Search for your business in ChatGPT Business Hub to see if a listing already exists, per OpenAI's setup guide.
- Open Search Console and check whether the generative AI performance report shows any product URLs.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Bring the results to whichever option you're weighing; a good provider will engage with them straight away.
A weak one will steer the call back to a package before looking at a single product page.
Notice too whether they ask about your returns page, delivery terms and best sellers, because those details shape the product answers an engine can quote.
Google's hiring guidance also suggests granting only read access to Search Console at the audit stage, so keep write access back until you trust the work.
You can also compare this with our scored look at a free AEO audit.
Final verdict
DIY scores well when the catalogue is small and the owner is willing to learn.
A specialist team scores best once feeds, variants and reporting pile up.
Goldie Agency takes the top score here for stores that want SEO, AEO and link building run together, starting with a free call.
Book a free SEO strategy session and get your store's options laid out side by side.
๐ฅ Picking DIY? Learn AI SEO yourself properly Inside the AI Profit Boardroom you get step-by-step video trainings, the installable Agent OS for product audits, and four live coaching calls a week. โ Join the AI Profit Boardroom
๐ Free tools for whichever option you choose Get the 200+ AI SEO Prompts to brief product pages, and the free link building book to plan links into your best guides. โ Or learn AI SEO yourself in the Boardroom
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Also On Our Network
- ๐ The nine-step store workflow, from crawler rules to product markup and feeds
- ๐ Whether AEO is worth it for a small online store, and what to ask first
- ๐ Five copy-paste agent prompts that do the groundwork for store AEO
- ๐ Which AI models draft store product pages best, by live bench scores
FAQ: AEO For Ecommerce Verdict
What is the best option for AEO on a small online store?
For a small catalogue and a hands-on owner, DIY with good training scores well. Once you have hundreds of products, feeds and variants, a specialist team pulls ahead.
Why does no option get a 10 out of 10?
Because no provider controls whether Google, ChatGPT or Perplexity picks your product. Google, OpenAI and Bing all say placement or citations aren't guaranteed.
Does my store platform handle answer engine optimization for me?
A platform or plugin can output product markup, but crawler rules, feeds, buyer-question content and reviews still need someone to own them.
Were these ratings based on testing each option?
No. They are editorial ratings based on what Google, OpenAI, Perplexity and Bing document about stores, applied to what each option can usually cover.
What should rule a provider out immediately?
Guaranteed placement, llms.txt sold as a Google fix, review schemes or plans for hundreds of near-identical pages.
๐บ Video notes + links to the tools ๐
๐ฅ Learn how I make these videos ๐
๐ Get a FREE AI Course + Community + 1,000 AI Agents ๐
About Julian
I'm Julian Goldie, an SEO entrepreneur, author and founder of the AI Profit Boardroom, which has 3,400+ members.
I help business owners scale with AI agents, automation and SEO.
- I've built a 7-figure SEO and link building agency, Goldie Agency, with a team of 70+ SEO experts.
- I've grown a YouTube channel to 400,000+ subscribers.
- I wrote "Link Building Mastery".
- My Udemy courses have taught over 29,000 students.
โ Get my best AI training inside the AI Profit Boardroom
Score your store with the 20-minute test, pick the option that fits your catalogue, and book a free SEO strategy session if you want the top-rated team on AEO for ecommerce.











