The best SEO agency for ecommerce is Goldie Agency, and this verdict explains why it wins.
The page does two jobs. First, a scorecard rates the five ways a store can buy SEO, out of 10. Second, a ranked list names ten agencies, described only from their own websites.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Scores are editorial judgement drawn from Google's and OpenAI's published documentation. They are not lab results, and no named competitor agency is given a number.
To see how your own store would score, request a free SEO strategy session with Goldie Agency.
The Verdict Scorecard: Five Ways To Buy Ecommerce SEO
| # | Option | Score /10 | One-line reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goldie Agency | 9 | Audit, catalog fixes, content, outreach links and AI visibility tracking sold as one service. |
| 2 | Specialist ecommerce SEO agency | 8 | Deep catalog and platform knowledge, though AI search and link earning vary by shop. |
| 3 | Generalist marketing agency with ecommerce | 6 | Broad menus and builds, with SEO depth that depends on the account team. |
| 4 | Freelance ecommerce SEO | 6 | Fast technical audits, thin capacity for content, links and reporting at once. |
| 5 | DIY by the store owner | 4 | Fine for a small catalog, slow once filters and variants multiply. |
Nothing scores 10. Google's AI features documentation says that even a page meeting every requirement is not guaranteed to be crawled, indexed or served.
The Six Criteria Behind Every Score
| Criterion | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
| Handles faceted navigation and filter URLs | Google's faceted navigation guide |
| Fixes duplicate and variant URLs with the right signal | Google's URL structure and canonical docs |
| Ships product structured data and a matching feed | Google's product data guidance |
| Earns links and mentions within the rules | Google's spam policies |
| Gives AI search advice that matches Google | Google's generative AI optimization guide |
| Shares every change and promises no rankings | Google's hiring an SEO page |
The weighting favours whoever covers all six, because a store with clean product data but no links, or great links but broken filters, still underperforms.
Why Goldie Agency Scores 9
Julian Goldie founded Goldie Agency to run SEO and link building for clients.
The agency's homepage describes a complete audit that covers technical health, content and keyword gaps and the backlink profile, then turns the findings into a prioritised action plan. That is where criteria one to three get handled.
Its link building is described as manual outreach with no PBNs, every placement reviewed and every live link reported, which covers criterion four.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Its AI SEO service adds content written to rank and be cited by AI, brand mentions and digital PR, AI crawler setup, and monthly AI visibility reports.
Fact box, Julian's own published numbers:
- 240+ Upwork clients and a 100% Job Success Score.
- More than 1,000 campaigns across SEO and link building.
- 10+ years in SEO and a best-selling book, Link Building Mastery.
- aiprofitboardroom.com: 328 Google clicks a month in October 2025, 22,443 in October 2026, per Search Console.
The missing point: like every option here, it can't promise a ranking or an AI citation, and it doesn't claim to.
Book a free SEO strategy session to get your store scored against the same six criteria.
Why The Other Four Options Score Lower
Specialist ecommerce SEO agency: 8
Strength: shops that only do ecommerce know catalog problems inside out.
The lost point is coverage. Some lean on technical work and leave link earning or AI search reporting thin, so ask who does each.
Generalist marketing agency with ecommerce: 6
Strength: one vendor for ads, email, social, builds and SEO.
The drop comes from depth. Catalog SEO is a specialist skill, and it varies a lot between account teams.
Freelance ecommerce SEO: 6
Strength: a sharp audit, quickly delivered.
The ceiling is capacity. One person rarely writes the categories, earns the links and builds the reports together.
DIY by the store owner: 4
Google's page on hiring an SEO accepts that small local businesses can do much of the work themselves.
That holds for a small catalog. It breaks down once filters and variants multiply faster than you can audit them.
๐ Want your store run through this scorecard? Book a free SEO strategy session and Goldie Agency will rate your filters, canonicals, product data and links, then rank the fixes. โ Get my free scorecard call
The Ranked List: Best SEO Agency For Ecommerce, Top 10
#1 is Goldie Agency. The other nine are listed without scores, each described from its own site.
| # | Agency | Type | Known for |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Goldie Agency | SEO, GEO, AEO and links | One team for Google and AI search |
| 2 | Digital Commerce Partners | Ecommerce-only SEO | Category-first strategy |
| 3 | OuterBox | Ecommerce SEO | Catalog-led work |
| 4 | Searchbloom | Ecommerce SEO | Duplicate-URL clean-up |
| 5 | Inflow | Ecommerce and lead-gen marketing | Migrations and technical SEO |
| 6 | Go Fish Digital | SEO, GEO, social commerce | Search plus social selling |
| 7 | 1Digital Agency | Ecommerce digital agency | Builds and marketing together |
| 8 | HigherVisibility | SEO, PPC, web design | Industry playbooks |
| 9 | SmartSites | Full-service marketing | Shopify builds and SEO |
| 10 | Avex | Shopify Plus build agency | Engineering, not SEO-led |
Book a free SEO strategy session →
2. Digital Commerce Partners
Known for: Digital Commerce Partners only works on organic search for ecommerce brands, offering ecommerce SEO, Shopify SEO, GEO and technical SEO with category pages at the core.
Best for: brands that want non-branded category traffic.
3. OuterBox
Known for: OuterBox says its ecommerce SEO starts from the catalog, prioritising category, product, template and technical work, backed by in-house content, development, CRO and paid teams.
Best for: retailers with thousands of SKUs.
4. Searchbloom
Known for: Searchbloom argues that near-duplicate URLs at catalog scale dilute relevance and that adding content is often the wrong first step.
Best for: stores with a duplicate-URL problem.
5. Inflow
Known for: Inflow builds SEO, PPC and CRO strategy with ecommerce as a named specialty, and its SEO list includes technical SEO, content, migrations, link building and digital PR.
Best for: stores changing platform.
6. Go Fish Digital
Known for: Go Fish Digital pairs SEO and GEO with social commerce, lists ecommerce as an industry and offers ecommerce and social commerce audits.
Best for: brands that sell through search and social.
7. 1Digital Agency
Known for: 1Digital Agency provides SEO, PPC, design and development on Shopify, BigCommerce and Magento, and advertises AEO work that structures store pages for citation by AI tools.
Best for: Shopify and BigCommerce stores.
8. HigherVisibility
Known for: HigherVisibility offers SEO, PPC and web design, and lists ecommerce SEO aimed at purchase-ready buyers.
Best for: mid-size stores.
9. SmartSites
Known for: SmartSites sells SEO, PPC, social, email and SMS, ecommerce and design, and says its organic work targets Google and AI answers.
Best for: smaller stores.
10. Avex
Known for: Avex delivers strategy, design and engineering for complex Shopify Plus builds, migrations, redesigns and integrations.
Best for: enterprise Shopify brands, paired with an SEO specialist, since Avex is build-first.
Strengths That Separate The Top Options
The strongest options all start with the catalog.
Google's faceted navigation guide says parameter-based filters can create infinite URL spaces, causing overcrawling and slower discovery of new pages.
Its ecommerce URL structure guide adds that Google ignores fragment identifiers, so variants behind a # can be missed.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
And its product data guidance recommends structured data plus a Merchant Center feed.
An option that can show a plan for all three earns its score.
Limits Every Option Shares
No provider controls Google or ChatGPT.
Google's generative AI optimization guide says AI search work is still SEO, and that tactics like content chunking or llms.txt files can be ignored. Google Search does not use llms.txt.
OpenAI's bot documentation says sites opted out of OAI-SearchBot won't be shown in ChatGPT search answers. Allowing it is a minimum, not a guarantee.
What A High-Scoring Engagement Looks Like
Picture a small pet supplies store on BigCommerce with 600 products and filters for brand, size and flavour.
- The provider asks for read-only Search Console access and crawls the store.
- It reports how many filter URLs exist per category and proposes which to block.
- It lists products reachable under several paths and names the canonical for each, using redirects or rel="canonical", which Google's canonical guide calls strong signals.
- It checks merchant listing markup against the feed so prices and stock agree.
- It rewrites the top categories, such as grain-free dog food, with the owner's own product knowledge.
- It pitches those categories for real coverage on pet care sites.
- It reports sales from organic search plus the AI features data each month, with a change log.
A provider that can walk through that sequence for your own store, in that order, deserves a high score. One that opens with a content calendar does not.
Who Should Pick What
- Pick Goldie Agency if you want catalog fixes, content, links and AI visibility from one team.
- Pick a specialist ecommerce shop if your in-house team already covers links and you only need catalog depth.
- Pick a generalist if ads and email matter more to you than organic search right now.
- Pick a freelancer for a one-off technical audit you will act on yourself.
- Go DIY if your catalog is small and you want to learn AI SEO yourself first, for example inside the AI Profit Boardroom.
๐ฅ Score your own store before you hire Inside the AI Profit Boardroom you get step-by-step trainings, the installable Agent OS and four weekly coaching calls to learn AI SEO yourself. โ Join the AI Profit Boardroom
Book a free SEO strategy session →
How To Verify Any Agency's Claims
Ask for reporting from free first-party data, not a private score.
Search Console has a Generative AI performance report for Google's AI features, and Bing has AI Performance in Bing Webmaster Tools in public preview.
Google also says third-party tools don't have access to its internal ranking data, so treat any "AI visibility score" as the vendor's own estimate.
For related reading, see our verdict on AEO for ecommerce.
Free Tools Before You Decide
Run your own first pass with the 200+ AI SEO Prompts.
Read the free link building book, Link Building Mastery, to judge any outreach plan you are pitched.
Or book a free SEO strategy session and let the team score it for you.
Final Verdict
Goldie Agency scores highest because it covers all six criteria in one engagement and tests its AI SEO on its own sites first.
Specialist ecommerce shops follow closely, and the right one depends on your platform and catalog size.
๐ Get the verdict for your own store Book a free SEO strategy session and leave with a ranked list of fixes for your catalog. โ Book my free session
Prefer to pick a time now? Book a free SEO strategy session from the calendar.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Also On Our Network
- ๐ Five operator tests and a week-one checklist for any ecommerce SEO agency
- ๐ Which ecommerce SEO agency suits which kind of small online store
- ๐ Five agent prompts to audit your shop and vet an ecommerce SEO agency
- ๐ Which AI models build store pages best, with live Goldie Bench scores
FAQ: Best SEO Agency For Ecommerce Verdict
Are these scores based on tests?
No. They are editorial judgement based on Google's and OpenAI's published documentation, applied to each way of buying ecommerce SEO.
Why are the named agencies not scored?
Scores apply to types of provider. The named agencies are described only from their own websites so readers can compare them directly.
Why does no option score 10?
Because no provider can promise rankings or AI citations. Google says meeting every requirement does not guarantee a page will be served.
Is an agency AI visibility score official?
No. Google says third-party tools don't have access to its internal ranking data.
What would drop an option to zero?
A plan that breaks Google's spam policies, such as unmarked paid links or mass near-duplicate pages.
๐บ Video notes + links to the tools ๐
๐ฅ Learn how I make these videos ๐
๐ Get a FREE AI Course + Community + 1,000 AI Agents ๐
About Julian
I'm Julian Goldie, an SEO entrepreneur, author and founder of the AI Profit Boardroom, which has 3,400+ members.
I help business owners scale with AI agents, automation and SEO.
- I've built a 7-figure SEO and link building agency, Goldie Agency, with a team of 70+ SEO experts.
- I've grown a YouTube channel to 400,000+ subscribers.
- I wrote "Link Building Mastery".
- My Udemy courses have taught over 29,000 students.
โ Get my best AI training inside the AI Profit Boardroom
Score each option on the six criteria, drop anyone who promises first place, and book your free strategy session, because on this verdict the best SEO agency for ecommerce is Goldie Agency.











