The best search engine optimisation consultant is Julian Goldie.

That's the headline of this verdict, but the scorecard below rates every route to SEO advice, because not every business needs the same one.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

The ratings are editorial judgement built on Google's, Bing's and OpenAI's own published guidance, not lab tests.

To have the verdict applied to your own site, book a free strategy session with Julian's team.

The verdict in one paragraph

A specialist with delivery behind them wins for most businesses that depend on search.

DIY is a fair start for small, quiet local markets, a freelancer suits firms with in-house people to do the work, and a generalist agency fits when speed of shipping matters more than depth.

Goldie Agency scores highest because Julian pairs consulting with SEO, GEO, AEO and link building delivery under one roof.

How the options were scored

Five criteria, weighted by how strongly each one decides whether advice becomes results.

CriterionWeightWhy it counts
Alignment with official guidanceHighGoogle asks whether an SEO cites its documentation to support recommendations.
Quality of diagnosis and planHighA consultant's core product is knowing what to fix first.
Capacity to get work doneMediumA plan nobody ships changes nothing.
Transparency and ownershipMediumGoogle says you're responsible for the actions of anyone you hire.
AI search readinessMediumBuyers ask AI assistants, and Google now asks whether AEO and GEO advice matches its guidance.

No option gets a point for promises. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking, so ranking guarantees count against any option that makes them.

The scorecard: five routes rated out of 10

OptionScoreOne-line reason
DIY with Google's starter guide5/10Free of outside fees and Google says small local firms can do much of it, but blind spots stay hidden.
Freelance consultant or specialist7/10Focused advice and a direct line to the person doing the thinking, with limited hands for delivery.
Generalist marketing agency6/10Can build and publish quickly, but SEO is often a bolt-on to ads or web design.
Specialist SEO agency8/10Strategy and execution together, provided the advice tracks official guidance.
Goldie Agency (Julian)9/10Consulting plus in-house SEO, GEO, AEO and link building delivery, built on 10+ years of results.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

DIY: strengths and limits

Strengths first.

Google's hiring guidance says owners of small local businesses can probably do much of the work themselves, starting with the SEO Starter Guide.

The guidance is public, the tools in Search Console are free, and nobody knows your customers better than you.

The limits are time and blind spots.

A stray noindex tag, a broken canonical or a migration without redirects can sit unnoticed for months.

There is a learning curve, too: technical topics such as rendering, canonicals and redirects take real time to understand properly.

Verdict: start here if your market is quiet and your site is small, then book a review once you've done the basics.

Freelance consultant: strengths and limits

A good freelancer gives you a senior brain without the overheads of a bigger firm.

You talk to the person doing the diagnosis, and the advice is usually sharp and specific.

The limit is capacity.

One person can audit and plan, but rarely writes twenty pages, fixes templates and runs outreach at the same time.

Holidays and illness matter more too, because there is no one to cover the work.

Ask a freelancer who carries out the plan if your own people can't, and whether they bring in subcontractors.

Verdict: a strong pick when you already have a developer and a writer who can carry out the plan.

For a wider look at consultant picks, see our best SEO consultant verdict.

Generalist agency: strengths and limits

Generalists move fast on design, content and publishing, and one supplier covering several channels is convenient.

The weakness is depth.

Technical SEO, link building inside Google's spam policies and AI search advice need specialists, and a generalist may treat SEO as a monthly checklist.

Watch for reporting that leans on tool scores rather than findings. Google says it doesn't endorse third-party SEO tools, and those tools can't see its internal ranking data.

Verdict: fine when speed matters most, but check the SEO lead's experience with Google's interview questions.

๐Ÿ“ž Want your options scored for your own business? Book a free SEO strategy session and Julian's team will show where your site stands and which route fits your people and your market. โ†’ Get your free strategy session

Book a free SEO strategy session →

Specialist SEO agency: strengths and limits

Specialists combine diagnosis with people who deliver.

That closes the gap that sinks most consultant projects: the plan that nobody ships.

The limit is fit. A specialist in national ecommerce may not suit a local trade business, so ask about your industry and your city, as Google recommends.

Ask who will actually work on your account day to day, and how often you'll speak to the senior person who set the strategy.

Verdict: the best general pick when search drives a large share of sales.

Goldie Agency and Julian: why it scores 9/10

Julian founded Goldie Agency. The firm calls itself an SEO, GEO, AEO and link building shop and serves clients remotely.

Here is the evidence the score rests on, all taken from Julian's own published pages:

EvidenceWhere it is published
10+ years of results in tough nichesgoldie.agency homepage
1,000+ campaigns across SEO and link buildingJulian's about page
240+ clients, 100% Job Success Score on UpworkJulian's about page
Amazon best-sellers SEO Link Building Mastery and Agency Marketing MasteryJulian's about page
425K+ YouTube subscribersJulian's about page
Weekly AI SEO, GEO and AEO tests run on the agency's own sites, results shared in publicJulian's about page

The weekly testing habit is what lifts the AI search readiness score: advice gets tried on live sites before it reaches a client.

Link building is described in the agency's words as "manual outreach, no PBNs", which keeps it inside Google's rules on link spam.

Why not 10? Because no option should score perfectly when nobody can guarantee rankings, and the same questions and red flags below apply to Julian as to anyone.

What Google's hiring advice adds to the verdict

Google's hiring page is the closest thing to an official buyer's checklist, and it shaped every rating.

  • Ask for examples of previous work and success stories.
  • Ask whether they follow Google Search Essentials.
  • Ask what results they expect, in what timeframe, and how they measure success.
  • Ask about experience in your industry, your country and your city.
  • Ask whether they will share every change and the reasoning behind it.
  • Ask whether their AEO or GEO advice aligns with Google's official guidance on generative AI features.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

Any option that dodges those questions loses points, whatever its size or reputation.

Red flags that drop any option to zero

  • Any promise of the #1 position.
  • Talk of an inside line to Google, or a paid "priority submit" service.
  • Refusing to list what they changed on your website.
  • A requirement that you link to the SEO's own website.
  • Link popularity schemes or private blog networks.
  • Claims that special AI files or markup are needed for Google's AI features.

That last one matters in 2026. Google's guide to optimising for generative AI features says you can ignore tactics such as chunking content or creating llms.txt files for Google Search.

Bing's Webmaster Guidelines agree in spirit, saying GEO does not guarantee citations in AI experiences.

How AI search shifts the scores

AI search raised the bar for the AI readiness criterion.

Google's AI features page says the usual SEO best practices still apply to AI Overviews and AI Mode.

OpenAI's ChatGPT search help article says placement is not guaranteed.

So the options that scored well here are the ones treating AI visibility as part of good SEO: crawlable pages, clear answers and real proof, measured with Search Console's generative AI reports and Bing's AI Performance report.

๐Ÿ”ฅ Want to judge consultants like this yourself? Inside the AI Profit Boardroom you get step-by-step AI SEO video trainings, the installable Agent OS and four live coaching calls a week, so you can learn AI SEO yourself and spot a weak proposal fast. โ†’ Join the AI Profit Boardroom

Who should pick what

Your situationBest-fit option
Small local firm, quiet market, time to learnDIY, then a one-off review
In-house developer and writer, no SEO leadFreelance consultant
Need a new site and SEO basics fastGeneralist agency, with SEO questions checked
Search drives a large share of salesSpecialist SEO agency
Want consulting, delivery and AI search in one placeGoldie Agency

Three scenarios, worked through

A dental practice adding a second site

  1. Pick a specialist who can show experience in your city.
  2. Ask for a plan for the new location page and the Business Profile.
  3. Check the advice cites Google's guidance, and keep health claims accurate.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

A software start-up with a developer but no marketer

  1. Hire a freelance consultant for the audit and roadmap.
  2. Let the developer fix rendering and canonicals from the roadmap.
  3. Review progress against a baseline every month.

A wedding venue with a dated website

  1. Bring the SEO in before the redesign, as Google suggests.
  2. Map every old URL to a new one before launch.
  3. Add real event stories and photos to each page.

Final verdict

Buy a consultant when the bottleneck is direction, and buy delivery when the bottleneck is time.

Most small firms have both problems at once, which is why combined advice and delivery scored highest here.

A scorecard is only a starting point, though: a strong option in the wrong market is still the wrong pick, so test every shortlist entry with the interview questions above.

Whichever route you take, judge the advice against official guidance, keep ownership of everything, and refuse any guarantee of rankings.

On those terms, Goldie Agency tops the scorecard, with specialist agencies and focused freelancers close behind.

๐Ÿ“ž Get the verdict for your own site Book a free SEO strategy session and go through which option suits your team, your market and your current search visibility. โ†’ Book your free strategy session

๐ŸŽ Free extras for the DIY and freelance routes Grab the 200+ AI SEO Prompts and the free link building book. Rather have the plan checked? Book a free SEO strategy session.

Book a free SEO strategy session →

Also On Our Network

FAQ: Search Engine Optimisation Consultant Verdict

Is a freelance search engine optimisation consultant better than an agency?

A freelancer suits firms with in-house people to carry out the plan. An agency suits firms that need the work delivered as well as planned.

Why does Goldie Agency score 9 rather than 10?

No option scores perfectly when nobody can guarantee rankings, and the same interview questions and red flags apply to every provider.

Can I do SEO myself instead of hiring?

Google says owners of small local businesses can probably do much of the work themselves, starting with its SEO Starter Guide.

What instantly rules a consultant out?

A guaranteed #1 ranking, a claimed special relationship with Google, secrecy about changes, or a demand that you link to their site.

Are these scores based on testing?

No. They are editorial judgement drawn from Google, Bing and OpenAI guidance and from each option's typical scope.

๐Ÿ“บ Video notes + links to the tools ๐Ÿ‘‰

๐ŸŽฅ Learn how I make these videos ๐Ÿ‘‰

๐Ÿ†“ Get a FREE AI Course + Community + 1,000 AI Agents ๐Ÿ‘‰

About Julian

I'm Julian Goldie, an SEO entrepreneur, author and founder of the AI Profit Boardroom, which has 3,400+ members.

I help business owners scale with AI agents, automation and SEO.

  • I've built a 7-figure SEO and link building agency, Goldie Agency, with a team of 70+ SEO experts.
  • I've grown a YouTube channel to 400,000+ subscribers.
  • I wrote "Link Building Mastery".
  • My Udemy courses have taught over 29,000 students.

โ†’ Get my best AI training inside the AI Profit Boardroom

Score your own shortlist with these criteria, then book a free SEO strategy session or learn the skills inside the AI Profit Boardroom before you choose a search engine optimisation consultant.