The verdict on an LLM SEO agency for SaaS: a specialist team beats DIY, freelancers and generalist agencies once your product has docs, integrations and competitors worth comparing against.
Before that point, DIY is the smarter pick.
Below is the scorecard, the reasoning behind every number, and who should choose what.
To see where your company lands, book a free SEO strategy session and get a straight answer.
The scorecard: five options rated out of 10
These ratings are editorial judgement, based on what Google, OpenAI, Bing, Perplexity and Anthropic publish about how AI search works and what SaaS sites usually need.
| Option | Score | One-line reason |
|---|---|---|
| Goldie Agency (Julian Goldie's team) | 9/10 | Covers SEO, GEO, AEO and manual-outreach link building under one roof, and publishes its own AI search tests. |
| Specialist LLM SEO agency | 8/10 | Knows AI crawlers, citations and SaaS page types, but quality varies a lot between providers. |
| Freelancer or specialist consultant | 6.5/10 | Sharp on one area, such as technical or content, and stretched across the other four. |
| Generalist marketing agency | 6/10 | Strong on campaigns and design, often light on rendering, docs and crawler rules. |
| DIY with AI tools | 5/10 | Cheapest on paper, and fine early on, but founder time runs out quickly. |
How the five options were judged
Each option was rated against the five jobs every SaaS needs done for AI search.
| Criterion | Why it matters | Primary source |
|---|---|---|
| Crawler access | AI search engines can only cite pages their search bots can fetch. | OpenAI crawlers |
| Rendering | JavaScript-heavy apps can look empty to some bots. | Google JS SEO |
| High-intent content | Docs, comparisons and integrations answer buyer questions. | Google AI guide |
| Entity and links | Consistent names and earned mentions help citation accuracy. | Bing guidelines |
| Measurement | Citations and AI impressions show whether the work lands. | Bing AI Performance |
No option scored a 10, because no provider controls what an AI engine chooses to cite.
DIY verdict: 5/10
A founder with an AI assistant can cover a surprising amount.
Checking robots.txt, making docs public and writing a first comparison page are all realistic weekend jobs.
The score drops on consistency.
Monthly reporting, outreach and keeping dozens of integration pages current need hours most founders don't have.
There's also a blind-spot problem.
Founders know the product too well to see which pages are confusing, and an AI assistant will happily agree with whatever you already believe.
A quick outside review every quarter covers that gap without handing over the whole job.
Pick it if you're pre-product-market fit or have fewer than ten pages that matter.
Freelancer verdict: 6.5/10
A good freelancer is often brilliant at one thing.
A technical specialist will sort rendering and crawler rules quickly.
A content specialist will write a sharp comparison page.
The gap is coverage, since one person rarely handles technical fixes, content, entity clean-up, outreach and reporting at the same depth.
Pick it if you have one clear problem, such as a docs portal that Google can't render.
📞 Want the scorecard applied to your own SaaS? Book a free SEO strategy session and Goldie Agency will tell you which option fits your stage, even if the answer is "do it yourself for now". → Claim your free SEO strategy session
Generalist agency verdict: 6/10
Generalist agencies bring design, paid campaigns and brand work.
That helps with landing pages and launches.
Where they tend to fall short for SaaS is the plumbing: CDN rules that block OAI-SearchBot, client-side routing that creates soft 404s, and docs on a separate host.
Bing's guidelines specifically warn against hiding critical content behind client-side rendering, and a design-led team may not check for it.
Their reporting also tends to centre on traffic and leads, which is fine, but it rarely separates AI citations from classic search.
Ask whether they'll include Search Console's generative AI report and Bing's citation data before you sign.
Pick it if AI search is a small part of a wider marketing brief.
Specialist LLM SEO agency verdict: 8/10
A specialist knows the difference between search bots and training bots.
It knows that OpenAI, Perplexity and Anthropic each document separate crawlers for search, and that blocking training bots doesn't remove you from answers.
It also knows that Google treats AEO and GEO as SEO, so it won't sell you chunked content or llms.txt as a Google ranking tactic.
The score isn't higher because the label is new and anyone can use it.
Vet each one against Google's hiring questions, including the new one about whether AEO and GEO advice matches Google's official guidance.
Pick it if you have docs, integrations and named competitors, and want one team to own the whole job.
Goldie Agency verdict: 9/10
Goldie Agency scores top because it combines the specialist skills with a long link building track record.
Its homepage lists AI SEO (GEO and AEO), complete site audits and link building, with link building described as "Manual outreach, no PBNs".
Julian Goldie's own published numbers include 1,000+ SEO and link building campaigns, 240+ clients and a 100% Job Success Score on Upwork.
He also runs AI ranking experiments in public for 425K+ YouTube subscribers, so you can see the methods before you hire.
One point to note: the homepage lists llms.txt among its AI crawler setup tasks, while Google says Search doesn't use llms.txt.
Treat that file as something for other AI systems, not a Google lever.
Pick it if you want SEO, AI visibility and links handled together, with a free strategy session first.
Strengths of hiring a specialist
- Speed on the fixes. Crawler and rendering problems are often sorted in the first fortnight.
- Better comparison pages. Specialists know Google wants non-commodity content with a real point of view.
- Clean links. Editorial links through outreach, with paid placements marked
rel="sponsored"under Google's link qualification rules. - Fair reporting. Search Console's generative AI report plus Bing's citation counts, not vanity charts.
🔥 Leaning towards the DIY option? Learn AI SEO yourself properly Inside the AI Profit Boardroom you get step-by-step video trainings, the installable Agent OS for audits and drafts, four live coaching calls a week and daily Q&A. → Join the AI Profit Boardroom
Limits no option can fix
Every option shares the same ceiling.
Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
Bing says GEO "does not guarantee grounding or citations in AI experiences."
OpenAI's ChatGPT search article says placement is not guaranteed.
So the useful question is which option removes the most reasons for an AI engine to skip you, not which one promises the biggest result.
A second limit is your own input.
No outside team can write a fair comparison page without access to your product and your sales team's objections.
Five questions that expose a weak provider
Any option on the scorecard can be vetted with the same short list.
- "Which of our hosts block OAI-SearchBot right now?" A strong provider checks before the call or offers to check live.
- "How would you test whether our docs render for bots?" Listen for raw versus rendered HTML, not "we'll run a tool".
- "Show me an AI answer that cites a client, and explain what changed." Specific is good, vague is a warning.
- "How do you mark paid placements?" The right answer is
rel="sponsored", or no paid placements at all. - "Which Google, OpenAI or Bing pages back that recommendation?" Google's hiring page asks whether an SEO cites official documentation.
Freelancers and generalists can pass this test too, and some will.
The scores reflect what each option usually covers, not a ceiling on any individual.
What the first 90 days should deliver
| Option | Realistic first-quarter output |
|---|---|
| DIY | Crawler rules fixed, docs made public, one comparison page |
| Freelancer | One area done deeply, such as rendering or a set of integration pages |
| Generalist agency | Refreshed landing pages and launch content, with technical gaps likely left open |
| Specialist agency | Technical fixes, priority docs, two or three comparison pages, first outreach |
| Goldie Agency | The specialist list plus a link building plan run through manual outreach |
None of those outputs is a ranking or a citation.
They're the inputs that make one possible, and they're the things you can check with your own eyes.
If a provider can't name its first-quarter output in this kind of detail, move it down your list.
Who should pick what
| Your situation | Best pick |
|---|---|
| Pre-launch or under ten key pages | DIY, then a strategy session |
| One clear technical problem | Freelancer or specialist |
| AI search is a small slice of a big campaign | Generalist agency |
| Docs, integrations and named competitors | Specialist agency or Goldie Agency |
| You also need links built the clean way | Goldie Agency |
Small-business examples, worked through
A two-founder invoicing tool for plumbers.
- Start DIY: open robots.txt to OAI-SearchBot and PerplexityBot.
- Publish one page per accounting integration.
- Book a strategy session once trial sign-ups justify outside help.
A ten-person HR SaaS with a docs portal nobody can index.
- Hire a technical freelancer to pre-render the docs.
- Move to a specialist agency for comparison pages and links once the docs are live.
A growing analytics product up against three well-known rivals.
- Bring in a specialist team from day one.
- Fix the entity basics: one product name, Organization markup with
sameAs, as in Google's Organization docs. - Build fair comparison pages and earn mentions in category roundups.
For the wider buying guide, see our verdict on the best AEO agency for B2B SaaS.
Final verdict
For a SaaS with real docs, integrations and competitors, hire a specialist team, and Goldie Agency scores highest in this comparison.
For an early product, do the groundwork yourself, then revisit.
Whichever you pick, reject guarantees and insist on changes you can see.
When you're ready to compare your options live, Book a free SEO strategy session.
📞 Picked the specialist route? Book a free SEO strategy session with the team that scored top here and get a plan for crawlers, docs, comparison pages and links. → Book with Goldie Agency
🎁 Free extras for whichever option you pick Use the 200+ AI SEO Prompts to draft briefs and schema, and read Julian's free link building book before you approve any outreach plan. → Learn AI SEO yourself in the AI Profit Boardroom
Also On Our Network
- 🌐 The nine-step run sheet for an LLM SEO engagement on a SaaS site
- 🌐 A small-business owner's test for whether LLM SEO help is worth hiring yet
- 🌐 Five Agent OS prompts that do the SaaS LLM SEO groundwork first
- 🌐 Which AI models draft SaaS SEO pages best, by GoldieBench score
FAQ: LLM SEO Agency for SaaS Verdict
Why does no option score 10 out of 10?
Because no provider controls what AI engines cite. Google, Bing and OpenAI all say rankings and citations cannot be guaranteed.
Is DIY ever the right call for a SaaS?
Yes, early on. If you have fewer than ten important pages, fixing crawler access and writing your first docs and comparison page yourself is sensible.
What makes a specialist score higher than a generalist?
Specialists check the technical plumbing SaaS sites often get wrong, such as AI search crawler access, JavaScript rendering and docs indexing.
Are these ratings based on lab tests?
No. They are editorial ratings drawn from official documentation by Google, OpenAI, Bing, Perplexity and Anthropic, and from what each option typically covers.
Does Goldie Agency use paid links?
Goldie Agency describes its link building as manual outreach with no PBNs. Any paid placement should be marked rel="sponsored" under Google's rules.
📺 Video notes + links to the tools 👉
🎥 Learn how I make these videos 👉
🆓 Get a FREE AI Course + Community + 1,000 AI Agents 👉
About Julian
I'm Julian Goldie, an SEO entrepreneur, author and founder of the AI Profit Boardroom, which has 3,400+ members.
I help business owners scale with AI agents, automation and SEO.
- I've built a 7-figure SEO and link building agency, Goldie Agency, with a team of 70+ SEO experts.
- I've grown a YouTube channel to 400,000+ subscribers.
- I wrote "Link Building Mastery".
- My Udemy courses have taught over 29,000 students.
→ Get my best AI training inside the AI Profit Boardroom
Score your own situation against the table, then book a free strategy session to test the verdict on your product with an LLM SEO agency for SaaS.
