The best AI visibility tools, rated, are Ahrefs Brand Radar at 9.0, the Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit at 8.6 and Profound at 8.4, which makes Ahrefs Brand Radar our #1.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Every score on this page is ours: an editorial rating out of 10, based only on the features each tool publishes on its own website.
Price plays no part in any score.
If you want a second opinion on which one fits your site, get a free SEO strategy session with Goldie Agency.
The Verdict In One Line
Use the free Google and Bing reports as your baseline, then pick Ahrefs Brand Radar for the best mix of engine coverage and fast data, or Semrush if your team already works inside it.
How We Scored Each Tool
Each tool got a rating across five criteria, weighted equally, then rounded to one overall score.
- Engine coverage: how many AI engines the vendor names, by name, on its own pages.
- Prompt control: whether you can track your own questions as well as preset ones.
- Citation and source data: whether it shows the URLs and domains an answer cited.
- Speed to insight: whether useful data appears without a long setup.
- Data access: exports, API, MCP or dashboard connectors.
Where a vendor doesn't name its engines, the coverage score stays low until it does.
The Scorecard
| # | Tool | Our score /10 | One-line reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ahrefs Brand Radar | 9.0 | Seven named engines, custom prompts and a no-setup prompt index |
| 2 | Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | 8.6 | Deep feature set and AI Search Site Audit; engine list limited to ChatGPT and AI Mode |
| 3 | Profound | 8.4 | Seven named engines plus Shopping and Agent Analytics; built for larger teams |
| 4 | Otterly.AI | 8.2 | Seven engines, content audit, public API and MCP |
| 5 | Peec AI | 8.0 | Country and model segmentation, Looker Studio, API and MCP |
| 6 | AthenaHQ | 7.8 | Content agent and wide integrations; some engines only on higher tiers |
| 7 | Scrunch | 7.5 | Strong crawl feed and AXP; engines not named on its homepage |
| 8 | Rankscale | 7.4 | Widest claimed coverage at 17+ engines, with query fan-outs |
| 9 | Similarweb AI Search Intelligence | 7.2 | Best traffic view; lighter on prompt-level control |
| 10 | SE Visible | 7.0 | Solid basics and API on all plans; Claude and Copilot listed as coming soon |
Book a free SEO strategy session →
๐ Need help acting on the data? A score tells you where you stand. Goldie Agency's free AI visibility audit, inside a free SEO strategy session, tells you which page to fix first and why. โ Book a free SEO strategy session
The Free Baseline: Not Scored, Always Used
Two reports sit outside the scorecard because they are free and first-party.
Search Console's Generative AI performance report shows impressions for your site in AI Overviews and AI Mode, as Google explains in its report documentation.
Bing Webmaster Tools' AI Performance report, launched in public preview on 10 February 2026 according to the Bing announcement, shows citations in Copilot and Bing's AI summaries.
Bing calls it an early step toward GEO tooling, which is a fair description of the whole category.
Any paid tool should be read next to these two, never instead of them.
๐ฅ Learn AI SEO yourself and read these scores like a pro Inside the AI Profit Boardroom you get step-by-step AI SEO trainings, the Agent OS and four live coaching calls a week to turn visibility data into page fixes. โ Join the AI Profit Boardroom
Tool-By-Tool Verdicts
1. Ahrefs Brand Radar: 9.0
Strengths: Brand Radar names AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Copilot, with Claude on custom prompts. It pairs daily custom prompts with an AI Visibility Index that needs no setup, plus sentiment and the YouTube, TikTok and Reddit sources behind AI answers.
Limits: Ahrefs itself says the index works best for established brands or topics with real search demand, so a brand-new business leans on custom prompts.
Verdict: the strongest all-round pick for most buyers.
2. Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit: 8.6
Strengths: the toolkit documentation lists Visibility Overview, Competitor Research, Prompt Research, Brand Performance with share of voice and sentiment, Prompt Tracking and an AI Search Site Audit, with CSV and PDF export.
Limits: tracked engines are ChatGPT and Google AI Mode. Subusers need their own licences.
Verdict: the obvious choice for Semrush teams.
3. Profound: 8.4
Strengths: Profound names ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini, DeepSeek, AI Overviews and AI Mode, and adds Answer Engine Insights, Prompt Volumes, Shopping, Agent Analytics and benchmarking.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Limits: its positioning is enterprise, which can be more than a small site needs.
Verdict: best for marketing teams at bigger brands.
4. Otterly.AI: 8.2
Strengths: Otterly.AI tracks seven named engines and adds a content audit, GEO recommendations, agent crawl analytics, a public API and MCP.
Limits: lighter on the big-suite extras that Ahrefs and Semrush bundle.
Verdict: a strong pick for small teams that want monitoring and next steps in one place.
5. Peec AI: 8.0
Strengths: Peec AI reports visibility, position and sentiment, with prompt volumes, sources and recommendations, segmented by model and country, plus Looker Studio, API and MCP.
Limits: five named engines, fewer than the top four.
Verdict: best for multi-country reporting.
6. AthenaHQ: 7.8
Strengths: AthenaHQ adds a content optimization agent, citation analysis, PR monitoring and Ask Athena, with GA4, Search Console, Shopify and Webflow integrations.
Limits: engines such as AI Mode, Claude and Grok sit on higher tiers.
Verdict: good for teams that want a tool that suggests the fix.
7. Scrunch: 7.5
Strengths: Scrunch offers prompt and topic monitoring, citations, an AI bot crawl feed and AXP, a machine-readable version of your site for AI agents.
Limits: the homepage says "major LLMs" without naming them.
Verdict: worth a look if AI agents reading your site is the priority.
8. Rankscale: 7.4
Strengths: Rankscale says it covers 17+ engines and adds query fan-outs, page audits and prompt research.
Limits: the REST API sits on an upper plan.
Verdict: pick it for breadth of engines.
9. Similarweb AI Search Intelligence: 7.2
Strengths: Similarweb compares AI traffic and referrals with competitors and adds prompt, citation and sentiment analysis.
Limits: the focus is traffic, so prompt-by-prompt work is less central.
Verdict: best if referral traffic is the number you report.
10. SE Visible: 7.0
Strengths: SE Visible tracks AI Mode, AI Overviews, Gemini and ChatGPT, with share of voice, sentiment, citations by domain or URL and an API on all plans.
Limits: Claude and Copilot are listed as coming soon.
Verdict: a sensible add-on for existing SE Ranking users.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Score Breakdown For The Top Three
Here is how the five criteria split for the three leaders. These are our editorial ratings from each vendor's published features.
| Criterion | Ahrefs Brand Radar | Semrush toolkit | Profound |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engine coverage | 9 | 7 | 9 |
| Prompt control | 9 | 9 | 8 |
| Citation and source data | 9 | 9 | 9 |
| Speed to insight | 10 | 9 | 8 |
| Data access | 8 | 9 | 8 |
Ahrefs pulls ahead on speed because of its pre-collected prompt index. Semrush loses ground on coverage because it names only two engines. Profound matches Ahrefs on coverage but expects a bigger rollout.
How To Test This Scorecard On A Trial
Most vendors offer a demo or a trial. Use it to check our ratings against your own site:
- Load the same ten customer questions into each tool you trial.
- Note which engines actually return data for those questions.
- Check whether cited URLs are shown for every answer.
- Export the results and see if the file is usable without clean-up.
- Compare the brand mentions with what your Bing citation report shows.
What The Whole Category Does Well
- Shows whether AI answers name you, and who they name instead.
- Shows which pages and outside sources AI engines lean on.
- Tracks sentiment, which no free report covers.
- Covers engines Google and Bing can't report on, such as ChatGPT, Perplexity and Claude.
Where Every Tool Falls Short
- No inside view of Google. Google's guidance on SEO help states that third-party tools have no access to its internal ranking data and that Google does not endorse them.
- Samples, not totals. Answers vary by user, place and time.
- No control. A tool can't put you in an answer. Google's AI features page says normal SEO best practices are what count for AI Overviews and AI Mode.
- Moving targets. Engine lists and features change, so re-check vendor pages before renewing.
Who Should Pick What
- Most businesses: Ahrefs Brand Radar.
- Semrush customers: the Semrush toolkit.
- Enterprise marketing teams: Profound.
- Small teams that want next steps: Otterly.AI or AthenaHQ.
- Multi-country brands: Peec AI.
- Traffic-first reporting: Similarweb.
- Widest engine list: Rankscale.
Who Shouldn't Buy One Yet
A site with no AI impressions in Search Console and no citations in Bing has a content problem, not a tracking problem.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Example for a new local bakery:
- Check both free reports. If they're empty, skip the paid tool.
- Write clear pages for the questions customers ask, such as "gluten-free birthday cake [town]".
- Get listed accurately on the directories and review sites locals use.
- Re-check the free reports after a few weeks, then revisit this scorecard.
๐ Want the fixes done for you? Goldie Agency's AI SEO service covers cited content, brand mentions and digital PR, AI crawler setup and monthly AI visibility reports. Julian's own published numbers: 10+ years in SEO, 240+ Upwork clients and a 100% Job Success Score. Start with a free strategy session. โ Book a free SEO strategy session
Final Verdict
Ahrefs Brand Radar earns 9.0 and the top spot for coverage, prompt control and instant data.
Semrush and Profound follow closely, each the better choice for a specific kind of team.
For small teams on a lean setup, Otterly.AI at 8.2 is the one to shortlist next, with its content audit, public API and MCP built in.
Whatever you buy, keep Search Console and Bing as the first-party check on every number it shows you.
Free Tools Before You Pay For One
Use the 200+ AI SEO Prompts to write the questions you track, and read Julian's free link building book, Link Building Mastery, for the mentions work that moves the scores.
Want to learn AI SEO yourself? Join the AI Profit Boardroom. Want it handled? Book a free SEO strategy session.
For our verdict on the free route, see the free AEO audit review.
Book a free SEO strategy session →
Also On Our Network
- ๐ The five-step routine that turns an AI visibility tool into a weekly fix list
- ๐ Which AI visibility tool a local firm, shop or B2B service actually needs
- ๐ Five Agent OS prompts that turn AI visibility exports into a weekly gap list
- ๐ Which AI models turn AI visibility exports into reports, with live bench scores
FAQ: Best AI Visibility Tools Verdict
Which AI visibility tool scores highest?
Ahrefs Brand Radar, at 9.0 on our editorial scorecard, for seven named engines, custom prompts and a no-setup prompt index.
How were the scores worked out?
Five equally weighted criteria: engine coverage, prompt control, citation data, speed to insight and data access, judged only from each vendor's own published features.
Why are the free Google and Bing reports not scored?
They are free first-party data. They sit outside the scorecard as the baseline every paid tool should be checked against.
Is a higher score a guarantee of better AI visibility?
No. A tool only measures. Your pages, mentions and reviews are what change AI answers.
Should a new business buy an AI visibility tool?
Usually not at first. If the free reports show nothing yet, put the time into answer pages and accurate listings.
๐บ Video notes + links to the tools ๐
๐ฅ Learn how I make these videos ๐
๐ Get a FREE AI Course + Community + 1,000 AI Agents ๐
About Julian
I'm Julian Goldie, an SEO entrepreneur, author and founder of the AI Profit Boardroom, which has 3,400+ members.
I help business owners scale with AI agents, automation and SEO.
- I've built a 7-figure SEO and link building agency, Goldie Agency, with a team of 70+ SEO experts.
- I've grown a YouTube channel to 400,000+ subscribers.
- I wrote "Link Building Mastery".
- My Udemy courses have taught over 29,000 students.
โ Get my best AI training inside the AI Profit Boardroom
Score your shortlist against the five criteria, keep the free reports as your check, and claim a free strategy session if you want help choosing between the best AI visibility tools.











