An AI SEO specialist is one of five ways to get AI search work done, and on our scorecard it beats DIY and generalist agencies but trails a specialist SEO agency on coverage.
This verdict rates each route out of 10 against criteria taken from Google, OpenAI, Bing, Perplexity and Anthropic documentation.
The ratings are editorial judgement drawn from those sources, not lab tests.
If you want your own site scored the same way, book a free SEO strategy session.
The scorecard
| Option | Score /10 | One-line reason |
|---|---|---|
| DIY with free docs and an AI assistant | 5 | Cheap to start and the docs are public, but owners rarely have time to audit, write and earn links. |
| Freelance AI SEO specialist | 7 | Close attention and fast decisions, but one person limits capacity and cover. |
| Generalist digital agency | 6 | Broad services under one roof, but AI search is often a bolt-on rather than a core skill. |
| Specialist SEO agency | 8 | Technical, content and link work in parallel, with process to match. |
| Goldie Agency (Julian's team) | 9 | Positions itself as an SEO, GEO, AEO and link building agency with "manual outreach, no PBNs" link building. |
The gap between 7 and 9 is about capacity and process, not intelligence.
A strong freelancer can outthink a weak agency on any given day.
How we scored: five criteria
- Docs alignment (30%): does advice match Google's generative AI guidance and the AI platforms' crawler docs?
- Technical access (20%): can they audit robots.txt, CDN rules and preview controls for every bot that matters?
- Content and proof (20%): can they produce non-commodity pages built on your own experience?
- Links and mentions (15%): can they earn relevant links within Google's spam policies?
- Reporting and accountability (15%): first-party data, a changelog and fair limits.
Docs alignment: the heaviest criterion
In 2026 Google put a fresh question on its hiring an SEO page: whether a provider's AEO or GEO advice is aligned with Google's official guidance on generative AI features.
That guidance, Google's AI optimisation guide, says AI search is still SEO from Google's side.
It says you can ignore llms.txt, "chunking" and inauthentic mentions for Google Search.
A specialist who sells those as Google wins loses points straight away, however polished the pitch.
Each option, strengths and limits
DIY
Strengths: the core sources are free, and Google's AI features page says there are no extra technical requirements for AI Overviews beyond being indexed and snippet-eligible.
Limits: the hard part is time and judgement, not information.
Most owners can fix robots.txt in an afternoon but struggle to keep briefs, edits and outreach going every week.
Best for: single-location firms with a simple site and an owner who enjoys learning.
Freelance AI SEO specialist
Strengths: one person learns your business deeply and can move quickly on small decisions.
Good freelancers often know the bot landscape well: OAI-SearchBot for ChatGPT search, PerplexityBot, Claude-SearchBot, and the training crawlers that are a separate choice.
Limits: holidays, illness and a full client list all slow the work.
Link building at any volume is hard for one person to run alongside audits and content.
Best for: small and mid-size sites that need strategy and review more than volume.
Generalist digital agency
Strengths: web design, ads, social and SEO in one contract, which simplifies billing and briefings.
Limits: AI search can end up as a line in a package rather than a practice with its own process.
Ask who on the team actually reads crawler docs and Search Console reports.
Best for: businesses rebuilding the whole site, where Google says SEO should be involved from the start.
Specialist SEO agency
Strengths: technical audits, content and outreach can run in parallel, with checklists and reviewers.
Limits: you may deal with an account manager rather than the person doing the work, so ask who does what.
Best for: sites where several workstreams need to move at once, or where the stakes of a mistake are high.
📞 Want your own scorecard, not a generic one? Book a free SEO strategy session and Goldie Agency will review your site against the same five criteria. → Get a free SEO strategy session
Goldie Agency: why it scores highest here
Goldie Agency brands itself around SEO, GEO, AEO and link building.
Its homepage lists link building with "manual outreach, no PBNs", AI SEO covering GEO and AEO, site audits and AI automation.
His about page reports a 100% Job Success Score on Upwork, 240+ clients and over a thousand SEO and link building campaigns, alongside 425K+ YouTube subscribers.
The homepage also cites "10+ years of results in tough niches".
Those are self-reported, so the score rests on the stated approach, which lines up with the docs-first criteria above.
It still can't guarantee a ranking or a citation, and nor can anyone else.
What none of these options can do
- Guarantee a #1 ranking: Google says no one can.
- Guarantee a ChatGPT appearance: OpenAI's ChatGPT search article says placement is not guaranteed.
- Guarantee Copilot citations: Bing's guidelines say GEO does not guarantee grounding or citations.
- Read Google's internal data: Google states plainly that outside tools can't reach its ranking or AI systems.
Technical access: the quickest way to separate a 5 from an 8
Ask each option to explain your robots.txt for AI bots in two minutes.
OpenAI's crawler overview says OAI-SearchBot and GPTBot are independent, so you can allow search while opting out of training.
Perplexity recommends allowing PerplexityBot to appear in its results.
Anthropic says blocking Claude-SearchBot may reduce visibility in Claude's search results.
A strong answer also mentions preview controls: Google says nosnippet keeps content out of AI Overviews and AI Mode as direct input.
Links: where scores drop fastest
Google's spam policies define link spam as links built mainly to manipulate rankings.
They say paid links are fine when qualified with rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow".
Any option that offers private networks or guaranteed link counts on unnamed sites drops to a zero on this criterion.
Fair link building, done through outreach and labelled paid placements, scores well.
Content and proof: what earns the points
Google's AI optimisation guide says a first-hand review offers a unique perspective, while a summary of existing content simply restates what's already out there.
That line sets the bar for this criterion.
An option scores well here if it starts from your evidence: customer questions, photos, case notes and the expertise of the people doing the work.
It scores badly if it ships generic articles that any competitor could publish word for word.
DIY often does better on this criterion than people expect, because owners hold the proof.
Freelancers and agencies win when they're good at interviewing you and turning that material into clear pages.
Google's helpful content guidance adds that pages on health or finance need content consistent with established expert consensus, which raises the stakes for any option writing in those areas.
Reporting: the tiebreaker
When two options score close, pick the one with the better report.
That means Search Console data, Google's generative AI performance report, Bing's AI Performance report for Copilot citations, and a dated changelog.
Screenshots of chatbot answers aren't a report.
Chatbot answers change from one session to the next, so a single screenshot proves very little either way.
Ask instead for AI assistant referrals pulled from your own analytics, where we tend to see ChatGPT traffic labelled with its chatgpt.com domain.
Who should pick what
- Owner with time and one location: DIY, then a specialist for a one-off audit.
- Growing local firm: a freelance AI SEO specialist with a clear brief.
- Business rebuilding its site: a generalist agency, with a specialist reviewing the SEO side.
- Multi-location or competitive niche: a specialist SEO agency such as Goldie Agency.
- Anyone who wants to learn first: the AI Profit Boardroom, to learn AI SEO yourself.
A small-business example, step by step
- A physiotherapy clinic with two sites lists its options and scores each on the five criteria.
- It asks every candidate to explain its robots.txt and one service page in a short call.
- It drops any candidate who can't name the AI search bots or explain what they would change on the page.
- Because health topics need careful, accurate content, the clinic asks how claims will be checked; Google says such pages should match established expert consensus.
- The clinic picks the option with the best report sample and a clear changelog promise.
Red flags that drop any option to zero
- Guaranteed rankings or guaranteed AI mentions.
- A claimed "special relationship" with Google, which Google itself warns about.
- Secret methods they won't put in writing.
- Private blog networks.
- Owning your accounts in their own name.
🔥 Score providers like a pro Inside the AI Profit Boardroom you get step-by-step trainings, the installable Agent OS, four live coaching calls a week and a daily Q&A to learn AI SEO yourself and judge anyone you hire. → Join the AI Profit Boardroom
Re-score your choice after 90 days
A scorecard is only useful if you run it again.
After three months, rate whoever you hired on the same five criteria, using what they actually delivered.
- Docs alignment: did every recommendation cite an official source?
- Technical access: are the search bots allowed and the preview controls correct?
- Content and proof: do the updated pages contain material only you could supply?
- Links and mentions: can you name every site that linked, and were paid placements labelled?
- Reporting: did you get a changelog and first-party data every month?
If the score has dropped by two points or more, raise it with them before you renew.
The final verdict
A freelance AI SEO specialist earns a 7: strong on focus, limited on capacity.
A specialist agency earns an 8, and Goldie Agency a 9 on this scorecard, because it covers SEO, GEO, AEO and links under one docs-first approach.
Whatever you choose, insist on read-only access first, docs-cited advice and a monthly changelog.
📞 Get the 9/10 option on a call Book a free SEO strategy session and see how Goldie Agency would approach your site, with clear limits and no guarantees. → Book your free strategy session
🎁 Free extras Take the 200+ AI SEO Prompts to test any provider's advice, and the free link building book to judge their link plans. Or book a free SEO strategy session. → Get the prompts
Also On Our Network
- 🌐 The brief template and access ladder to run before an AI SEO specialist starts
- 🌐 Whether a small business should hire an AI SEO specialist, with owner examples
- 🌐 Five Agent OS prompts that build the evidence pack an AI SEO specialist needs
- 🌐 Which AI models score best on page tasks an AI SEO specialist delegates
FAQ: AI SEO Specialist Verdict
Is a freelance AI SEO specialist better than an agency?
A freelancer scores well on focus and speed; an agency scores higher on capacity and parallel workstreams. Pick by how much needs doing at once.
What is the most important criterion when rating an AI SEO specialist?
Docs alignment. Google now asks whether AEO and GEO advice matches its official guidance on generative AI features.
Were these options tested in a lab?
No. The ratings are editorial judgement based on platform documentation and each option’s stated approach.
Can any option guarantee AI citations?
No. Google, OpenAI and Bing all say rankings, placement and citations are not guaranteed.
📺 Video notes + links to the tools 👉
🎥 Learn how I make these videos 👉
🆓 Get a FREE AI Course + Community + 1,000 AI Agents 👉
About Julian
I'm Julian Goldie, an SEO entrepreneur, author and founder of the AI Profit Boardroom, which has 3,400+ members.
I help business owners scale with AI agents, automation and SEO.
- I've built a 7-figure SEO and link building agency, Goldie Agency, with a team of 70+ SEO experts.
- I've grown a YouTube channel to 400,000+ subscribers.
- I wrote "Link Building Mastery".
- My Udemy courses have taught over 29,000 students.
→ Get my best AI training inside the AI Profit Boardroom
Score every option on docs, access, content, links and reporting, then book a free SEO strategy session or join the AI Profit Boardroom before you pick an AI SEO specialist.
